Barbara Ramirez lives a double life every day. Sa umaga, siya ang siga ng Charleston Academy. Sa gabi, siya si notanotherfairytale, ang writer ng sikat na online love story na You’re The One That I Want. She successfully hides this alter ego from everybody until Cyrus Casabueno—the very same guy she based her story’s main character on— discovers her secret and offers help to improve her story in exchange for his silence. As her online love story progresses, Barbs finds herself falling in love for the first time—something na hindi niya kailanman inaasahan sa huling taon niya sa high school. Is falling in love in real life worth it, o mas mabuti pang lunurin na lang niya ang sarili sa ideal love na hatid ng fiction?